Jump to content
Maestronet Forums

/


chiaroscuro_violins
 Share

Recommended Posts

Mass made bow (German?) .. Look tip and frog.

Someone remade tip - revarnished (seem that does not know the job since looks unsealed/or bad varnished). Also messed up with tip corners at the back side.

Frog is out of commenting - button too (out of center). Grip.. Off comment too. Put at least that leather straight... 

What does your bow maker mean - it is a good stick? 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Mik Kyklo said:

Frog is out of commenting - button too (out of center). Grip.. Off comment too. Put at least that leather straight... 

What does your bow maker mean - it is a good stick?

I wouldn't jump at such strict conclusions by just watching few poor phone pics... The phone lens include HUGE distortion and what is in reality straight can be wavy or curved on phone(y) picture...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, HoGo said:

strict conclusions by just watching few poor phone pics

I agree. You are right. But, if you make some frogs, screws etc.--- you can realize some things immediately... And I had very strict instructor... 

14 minutes ago, chiaroscuro_violins said:

"numbers" are spot on.  Weight, balance, graduations, etc.

So, you mean it has good playing properties (Stiffness, Balance, weight etc). Ok , if you like how it plays, it is another thing / personal. Did I comment on that? No. If it plays great, that it is.

 

41 minutes ago, chiaroscuro_violins said:

This is interesting, because this is almost the opposite of what the bow maker said.  He had it in his hands.  We are not going to discuss his expertise because that is never productive and I won't tell you who he is.  He knows I am a violin maker (albeit still green), and he has my confidence.  

I never asked details about the bow maker. I asked you just about a phrase (nice stick).

Of course it would be unproductive to discuss about a bowmaker, because if you trust what someone told you, you do not ask at forum for extra opinions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, jacobsaunders said:

When I was a child, my father taught me, whenever an amateur violin maker came around to present his latest creation, to always say “oh, that is nice wood”

I think we need to be fair about things though...

And yes, the work of a beginner/amateur will never compare to the work of an expert, but...the early efforts of anyone starting anything new are a huge accomplishment and shouldn't summarily be dismissed either.

It is also very brave for a beginner to ask an expert for feedback. It's not hard to offer up constructive criticism that is still encouraging.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Rue said:

I think we need to be fair about things though...

And yes, the work of a beginner/amateur will never compare to the work of an expert, but...the early efforts of anyone starting anything new are a huge accomplishment and shouldn't summarily be dismissed either.

It is also very brave for a beginner to ask an expert for feedback. It's not hard to offer up constructive criticism that is still encouraging.

All very true, but Jacob's comment is also spot on. It is essential to have something positive to say when faced with someone's pride and joy that is objectively, let us say, not great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

46 minutes ago, chiaroscuro_violins said:

Ok, let's address a couple things.  

This is great advice.  In the past, I have been guilty of trying to impress violin makers with my crap work that I didn't yet know was crap.  "That's nice wood" went a long way.  

At this point, I would be a little insulted if that's all someone had to say about my fiddles.  I still very much classify myself as an amateur/student luthier, but I like to think I'm at the point now where there are areas to genuinely compliment, and in the areas to improve, I like to think I'm committed enough to benefit from criticism.  

That said, I don't pester violin makers anymore because I've grown up and realized how obnoxious it is.  

(Except here.  You guys are stuck with me)

This bow isn't my "pride and joy."  I have no horse in this race.  I just like it and don't know what it is, so I wanted to learn more by posting it here.  I know nothing about bows except how to use them.  I want to expand my knowledge, using a bow I own as the subject.  I like the bow just as much even though I now know it isn't anything special.  

I also don't think it's entirely fair to say the bow is "objectively not great."  As I said, I am NOT knowledgeable about bows, at least from an ID/appraisal standpoint.  However, I do fancy myself pretty knowledgeable about bows from the perspective of a violinist.  This bow just plays great.  There's no two ways about it.  I'm sure something from a big-name maker would play better.  But this bow plays as well as the best I've tried, and it actually costs less than my car.  :)

The frog and screw are not original to the stick.  I don't disagree with your attribution of the bow.  But these elements are not useful to determine where the stick came from.  

He took measurements of it, balanced it, weighed it, played it.  He said it was a nice stick.  Because people on this forum obviously don't agree (despite having never played it??), I was attempting to quell ad-hominem attacks from various users (not you specifically).  These things always happen and are just a waste of time.  Also, I don't distrust the bowmaker.  He is primarily a maker, not an appraiser, so I was never expecting him to tell me everything about this bow.  I brought it here to learn more about it, not because I thought he was wrong.  

Ultimately, I don't think the bow maker was just being nice about it.  He pointed out several things he didn't like and several things he was concerned about.  What would be the purpose of deliberately misleading an up-and-coming luthier?  Surely that would come back to bite you in the ass?  Overall, he just thought it was a nice bow.  He did NOT say it was valuable, and he thought the price I paid for it was fair.  

You asked why he called it a good stick.  

My comment was addressed directly to Rue's, and not to your original post. I am not qualified to offer an opinion on your bow and did not do so. It was not my intent to offend either you or your bow.:wacko:

Edited by Televet
Sense from nonsense
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...