Top 10 Historical Soloists - your vote


Recommended Posts

1. Kreisler (4 votes)


2. Paganini (4)


3. Heifetz (4)


4. Milstein (3)


5. Menuhin (4)


6. Oistrakh (3)


7. Thibaud


8. Grumiaux 


9. David


10. Joachim


11. Fodor


12. Szeryng (2)


13. Ysaye (3)


12. Elman


13. Vivaldi (2)


14. Szigeti 


15. Zimbalist


16. Rabin (2)


17. Mozart


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 93
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

One person whose recordings I never tire of listening to is Oscar Shumsky. That is my vote.

If you are unfamiliar with him, please take some time to dig up recordings on youtube, especially his interpretations of the Kreisler works.

Link to post
Share on other sites

All of the above violinist are indeed worthy,  however if they all played the same work, how many people could tell who was who?   Heifetz stood apart with his own sound.

 

I think Stephane Grappelli should be considered due to his creativity, uniqueness, and being instantly recognizable.  Even Menuhin admired his talent.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kreisler (4 votes)


2. Paganini (4)


3. Heifetz (4)


4. Milstein (3)


5. Menuhin (4)


6. Oistrakh (3)


7. Thibaud


8. Grumiaux 


9. David


10. Joachim


11. Fodor


12. Szeryng (2)


13. Ysaye (3)


12. Elman


13. Vivaldi (2)


14. Szigeti 


15. Zimbalist


16. Rabin (2)


17. Mozart


18. Shumsky


19. Grappelli


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kreisler (4 votes)


2. Paganini (4)


3. Heifetz (4)


4. Milstein (3)


5. Menuhin (4)


6. Oistrakh (3)


7. Thibaud


8. Grumiaux 


9. David


10. Joachim


11. Fodor


12. Szeryng (2)


13. Ysaye (3)


12. Elman


13. Vivaldi (2)


14. Szigeti 


15. Zimbalist


16. Rabin (2)


17. Mozart


18. Shumsky


19. Grappelli


20. Campoli


21. Ricci


22. Francescatti.


Link to post
Share on other sites

While Kreisler was extremely impressive on several levels, he already got a bagful of votes.  I'm modifying my Mozart vote to one for Leopold, as a well-respected player and influential violin educator as well as one for Wolfgang, as the prototype of a touring violin prodigy, before he was known as a composer.  IMHO, both should be on any top-ten list.

Link to post
Share on other sites

^If we're going to take it that far afield, Bach obviously played the violin.  And Tartini or somebody was the grandaddy of everyone.

 

Let's try to limit it to top ten you have actually heard...  That way the #1 won't be a proto-ape plucking a Tarzan vine.  Or some microbe.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kreisler (5 votes)


2. Paganini (4)


3. Heifetz (4)


4. Milstein (3)


5. Menuhin (4)


6. Oistrakh (3)


7. Thibaud


8. Grumiaux 


9. David


10. Joachim


11. Fodor


12. Szeryng (2)


13. Ysaye (3)


12. Elman


13. Vivaldi (2)


14. Szigeti 


15. Zimbalist


16. Rabin (2)


17. Mozart, W.


18. Mozart, L.


19. Shumsky


20. Grappelli


21. Campoli


22. Ricci


23. Francescatti.


Link to post
Share on other sites

One person whose recordings I never tire of listening to is Oscar Shumsky. That is my vote.

If you are unfamiliar with him, please take some time to dig up recordings on youtube, especially his interpretations of the Kreisler works.

YESSS!

 

Perhaps we should start a list of top 10 "unsung heroes" and certainly Shumsky would make that list.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kreisler (5 votes)


2. Paganini (4)


3. Heifetz (4)


4. Milstein (3)


5. Menuhin (4)


6. Oistrakh (3)


7. Thibaud


8. Grumiaux 


9. David


10. Joachim


11. Fodor


12. Szeryng (2)


13. Ysaye (3)


12. Elman


13. Vivaldi (2)


14. Szigeti 


15. Zimbalist


16. Rabin (2)


17. Mozart, W.


18. Mozart, L.


19. Shumsky (2)


20. Grappelli


21. Campoli


22. Ricci


23. Francescatti.


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

1. Kreisler (5 votes)

2. Paganini (4)

3. Heifetz (4)

4. Milstein (3)

5. Menuhin (4)

6. Oistrakh (3)

7. Thibaud

8. Grumiaux 

9. David

10. Joachim

11. Fodor

12. Szeryng (2)

13. Ysaye (3)

12. Elman

13. Vivaldi (2)

14. Szigeti 

15. Zimbalist

16. Rabin (2)

17. Mozart, W.

18. Mozart, L.

19. Shumsky (2)

20. Grappelli

21. Campoli

22. Ricci

23. Francescatti.

 

 

I don't see proto-ape plucking a Tarzan vine on there.

Link to post
Share on other sites

LOL...no, you are only supposed to put in one vote for the one you think is worthy of being in the Top Ten...

 

But I have been very lax in my adherence to my own rules...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tartini Corelli Vieuxtemps Rode Kreutzer Dont Dancla Wienawski

 

 

Bull, Massart, Locatelli, Auer

 

 

I'd go for Kreutzer and Ole Bull as well.   :)

 

 

Ten? How are we to do this, when we haven't heard most of them?

 

But in keeping with the last few posts, Vieuxtemps, Wieniawski, De Beriot, Rode . . . Ernst, Bazzini

 

Did you all want to rethink your entries?  This wasn't supposed to be a list of every conceivable violinist that ever existed.  I will accept up your top 3 worthy candidates if that helps you make a (smaller) decision.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.