Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

1203 profile views

Violinjon's Achievements


Member (3/5)

  1. Thanks all for the illuminating thread, especially to Jason who took the time to explain the reasoning. I find German bows a fascinating topic
  2. Seems like Tarisio is being very cautious in their descriptions of German bows. There are many bows with contemporary certificates that Tarisio describes merely as "ascribing" the bows to certain makers. This is a change from their past practice, as far as I can tell.
  3. Sorry Andreas, I will discuss a completely unrelated topic! The violin sounds nice, I can't truthfully guess over the internet on a sound clip, sorry! To David - this instructor has a point. I believe if you watch any high level violinist closely you'll see that they never play with a completely perpendicult bow (or even worse, a bow tilting backwards). A slight tilt of the bow towards the fingerboard is very helpful in applying the weight of the bow and arm to push the contact point closer the bridge, which is creates a stronger and more focused sound (the focus could maybe be what he meant by sweet?). The bow tilt also helps keep the bow straighter at the tip. This increases volume. I'm talking about slight tilts, of course, which keep all of the bow hair still in contact with the string, not extreme tilts.
  4. I assume you are bothered by the high pitched mini-squeeks, especially obvious on the G string. I believe this is caused by the string not being sufficiently grabbed by the bow, which is the same fundamental cause of the famous squeaky e string. This can be solved by adding more weight to the bow stoke (not playing at the tip, for example, as you do in the video) but can also be caused by setup issues, lack of rosin, old or wrong strings, etc. Since you recently had your bow rehaired I think you might not have enough rosin or the rosin hasn't "settled" yet on the new hair - it can take a while for the new hair and rosin to blend and "behave" well.
  5. I think it's rather hard to get all these qualities in a synthetic string, plus reasonable projection. Amber is a good option, it isn't the darkest sounding but it is warm with a good approximation of gut string texture. Obligatos and Vision solo strings are both very dark, but at the expensive of most of the high frequency texture. Infeld Red is Thomastik's option for what you want. Actually the new Perpetual Cadenza strings are the most complex synthetic strings I've heard, although they are more warm than dark - vision solo is one of the darkest, but it is so focused that is a bit like a black hole on my violin, which is already rather dark. Tzigane I have less experience with but I think would also be a good choice. I would recommend trying Amber, Tzigane, and Perpetual Cadenza first and Obligato and Infeld Red if budget allows (I think the first three, which are more recent strings are likely superior).
  6. Piotr Pielaszek, who has been doing well in the violin making competitions this year, discusses tool marks in this video. He mentions that as varnish wears he expects them to become more noticeable. https://youtu.be/LeSF00969ro?t=1m44s
  7. Why not today? I think the back of th scroll is the easiest place to find tool marks, here is the back of my H. Derazey scroll showing some:
  8. Yes, the obvious answer would be the Eudoxa A string, which is a lovely sounding string but unfortunately isn't that stable tuning-wise. The Passione A is a very good bang-for the buck (tension wise) string but I feel that it will likely drown out the Eudoxa Stiff D. I've tried most strings on my violin, including many gauges of gut strings, and in terms of sound and playing qualities my favourite was a set of Eudoxa (non-stiff) in light gauge with an Oliv e. Unfortunately in terms of tuning stability and matching bowing technique professional work is rather difficult, so I am currently using the new Perpetual Cadenza strings, which are interesting because they are less focused (one could say complex or richer) than most synthetic strings. I would suggest you try the the Perpetual Cadenza A, if you can manage to order it separately. Another option would be the Warchal Amber A, which also has a more fuzzy/rich texture. As you said, in the end trying strings is really the only way. Words are too fuzzy. And you need to be secure about setup too - your string choice needs to agree with your instrument's setup.
  9. I am not the expert you want, but I do know that my H Derazey has a one piece top as well as back! I heard that was a feature of his, although alone it cannot of course be enough to identify with certainty.
  10. Here are photos of my real H Derazey for comparison. Sorry about your purchase. I also live in east Asia, and purchasing violins here, especially your area, can truly be the Wild West, as Martin states. Did you buy from a shop or an individual?
  11. Philip, I don't see prices collapsing in the long term except for student-level (IE mass produced Chinese) violins. Prices for well regarded makers of the past half century certainly haven't crashed. Keep in mind that the majority of people in the world live outside of the States and Europe, and are a lot poorer. Especially in Asia (where I live and am familiar with), music is seen as an important part of one's education for those who can afford it. As these educated people grow older, they might invest in an expensive instrument, even if not professional. I see this happening a lot over here. There are still a lot of poor people in China, not to mention other countries like Thailand, Vietnam, and Malaysia that are getting richer. I think demand for expensive quality instruments will only get stronger. Even "the usual" mass produced instruments from 100 years ago fetch a premium here...
  12. Guys, I really don't see how you all see this as some kind of pro-China conspiracy. The video uses words like "churned" to describe Chinese-made violins while highlighting the craftmanship and "authenticity" of Italian-made instruments. This is not good propaganda. In fact, the Mainland would probably view this as anti-China.
  13. The title is clickbait, but unfortunately/fortunately that's at least an international problem. I totally understand too. That kind of behaviour is totally unacceptable and you shouldn't have to go through all that pain. If it makes you feel better, here in Hong Kong I have never seen a Musilia but I've seen plenty of Musafias. People here love Italian violins and cases...
  14. Dmitri, I hate to keep beating you up (I love your cases). But the video is almost surely purchased from AFP (a French media organization...). Newspapers purchase content from the big Western press organizations all the time, including the SCMP. Here is a Spanish version using the same footage. https://es.euronews.com/2020/06/19/cremona-cuna-mundial-de-lutieres I'm not condoning the report itself. It's stupid. But there is no grand Chinese conspiracy here - maybe somewhere else You make think I am sensitive, but I think, especially during these times, distilling the truth is ever more important.
  15. As a westerner living in Hong Kong for many years, I know that. It is a newspaper trying to do its best. It is not copy and pasting from official propaganda. Yet. In fact, where is it copy and pasting from? The AFP. The video is surely a crib on this report, which came out the same time. Edit: crib is too harsh a word, it's purchased media from AFP. https://news.yahoo.com/violin-makers-tune-tradition-stradivarius-italys-cremona-042601151.html Saying this comes from "The Chinese Government" is false. Full stop.
  • Create New...